For many years 100% tied jigs with no tips, plastics, stingers, etc. But, this past Sept. I was forced to tie on a crank due to extreme weed fouling conditions(every cast!) and it worked like a charm often flipping off hanging weeds long enuf for fish to bite. So now, with the ice broken, not as attached to pure jigging and will have no compunction having to resort again to a crank or even hard metal.