dblevens said:
Most of the jigs I use have two different colors. Just take for example, Black/Purple. If that color is working good, you think its that color combo, or is it one of the colors that would probably work on any jig. Like maybe Chartruse/Purple on the same day. Also, if its the black, would a solid black work better than half black? Just some random thoughts I think as I'm waiting on a thump.
Different fish species have different visual abilities. My two primary targets are smallmouth bass and steelhead. In my experience, these fish are not that selective on colors. Usually, the biggest difference in the amount of fish hooked relates to if the jig is a light color or a dark color. For example, on a certain day, dark colors (black, brown, purple) with outperform light colors (white, yellow, tan). Then the next day light colors could be better!
That being said, I think the fancy looking jigs are more for the tiers pleaure than the fish's preference. I'm more concerned with using materials that "flow" underwater and make the jig look alive.
I've spent a lot of time powder coating heads, applying 3d eye, and using multi colors to imitate baitfish, but basic single color jigs with no eyes often catches just as many fish for me. However, I am a big fan of adding flash (e.g. crystal flash) to the tails for added attraction.