I vertical jig a large percentage of the time, and also fish a jig under a bobber quite a bit. What would you recommend for a tailing material for slow presentations like this?
Kiptail and bunny....both have a nice action, and seem to hold up quite well. Marabou does not seem as strong...have not tried bucktail, but should work as well as the kip..
I don't fish vert. all that much - when i do it is usually through the ice. I'd vote for a waxworm tail.
For action, depends what you are wanting..... i'd say rabbit for the fastest most fluid motion and kip or short buck tail for slowest and keeping a certain shape. Just my oppinion tho.