I know of no pair of gloves, individually, that will keep my hands completely warm and dry when handling fish in winter.
Keeping the fingers of my right hand warm and dry while cranking the reel is tough. Often, I suffer discomfort and lose some feeling and dexterity.
My best solution has been the combination of surgical latex gloves with fingerless wool or neoprene gloves fitted over them. Though, many times, I still find myself removing them from my right hand because of an intolerable loss of feeling and dexterity.